Best Car Accident Attorney in Indiana: Top 15 Lawyers (2025)

The injured victims must navigate medical bills, insurance claims, and legal complexities. Hiring the best car accident attorney can make a critical difference in the outcome of your case. Experienced attorneys help victims gather evidence, file claims, and negotiate with insurers to secure fair compensation. In 2022, Indiana saw 206,936 traffic collisions and 949 fatalities, underscoring the need for expert legal assistance. Even in other states like North Carolina and Texas, car crashes are rampant – Charlotte reported 32,932 accidents in 2023, and Houston had 65,931 crashes – so top car accident attorneys in cities like Charlotte, Houston, and Atlanta face similar challenges. This guide covers Indiana’s top-rated lawyers, key legal insights, and tips to choose the right attorney for best car accident attorney.

Indiana Car Accident Statistics and Law Overview

Indiana’s roads are busy, and crash statistics show how often accidents occur. For example, 2022 data report over 206,000 collisions in Indiana. Alarmingly, the number of fatalities rose from 2021 to 2022, reaching 949 people. Even as total crashes slightly decreased, the fatality rate stayed around 1.10 per 100 million VMT. Serious injuries also remain high: in 2022, there were 3,307 serious injuries from crashes, with projections showing a slight bump in 2023. These figures highlight the dangers on Indiana’s roads and the importance of legal expertise when a crash happens best car accident attorney.

In Indiana, the law follows a modified comparative fault rule. If you are more than 50% at fault, you cannot recover damages. Even if you are less than 50% at fault, any compensation will be reduced by your percentage of fault. For instance, if you were 30% responsible, your award is cut by 30%. An experienced attorney knows how to gather evidence (police reports, witness statements, video) to minimize your fault percentage. They can also point out factors (road conditions, driver behavior, etc.) that may shift liability onto the other driver. Understanding Indiana’s fault rules is crucial; a knowledgeable car accident lawyer can explain how these laws apply to your case and work to keep your fault under 50% so you remain eligible for compensation best car accident attorney.

For perspective, look at other cities: Charlotte’s population surge led to over 32,932 crashes in 2023, with 105 deaths and 16,066 injuries. Houston, with 2.3 million people, saw 65,931 accidents (20,752 injuries and 258 deaths) in one year. Atlanta (Fulton County) averaged 4,593 crashes monthly (~151 per day) during 2014–2018. These stats illustrate that anywhere you drive, the chance of a collision is real – and finding the best car accident attorney can help you recover physically and financially after a crash best car accident attorney.

Why Hire a Car Accident Attorney in Indiana?

Surviving a crash and recovering physically is hard enough. An attorney handles the legal and insurance side so you can focus on healing. Here’s why the right lawyer matters: best car accident attorney

• Local Legal Expertise: Indiana has specific rules (like the 50% fault cap). A local attorney knows state laws, statutes of limitations, and how Indiana courts typically assess crash cases. They also understand Indiana insurance requirements (e.g., minimum liability coverage, UM/UIM policies) best car accident attorney
• Maximizing Compensation: Skilled attorneys know all potential damages: medical bills, lost wages, future care, pain and suffering, and more. They use evidence to build a strong case and fight for maximum recovery. For example, one firm has recovered over $750 million for clients. These big results usually come from top firms that invest in resources and expertise.
• Contingency Fee (No Fee Unless You Win): Most car accident attorneys work on contingency – you pay no attorney fees unless they secure compensation. For instance, Keller & Keller prominently advertise “NO FEE Until We Win”. This fee structure gives you access to top attorneys without upfront cost best car accident attorney
• Handling Insurance Companies: Insurance adjusters aim to pay as little as possible. An attorney deals with insurers on your behalf, ensuring you are not short-changed on settlement offers. They know tactics insurers use and will negotiate to get you fair payment for your injuries.
• Navigating Complex Claims (Uber, Truck, Drunk Drivers): Some crashes involve extra complications. Rideshare crashes (Uber/Lyft) involve special insurance policies depending on the driver’s status. A knowledgeable Uber accident lawyer can explain which insurance kicks in and pursue all liable parties. Similarly, truck accidents involve federal regulations and higher stakes; attorneys who handle truck cases know to investigate driver logs and company liability best car accident attorney
• Investigative Resources: Top law offices have resources (experts, accident reconstructionists, medical professionals) to build your case. A full-service car accident law office will gather evidence (photographs, police reports, videos) and organize it effectively. They also coordinate with healthcare providers for medical documentation, proving the extent of your injuries best car accident attorney
• Legal Strategy and Advocacy: Beyond paperwork, a lawyer provides strategy. They know when to negotiate a settlement and when to take a case to court. For example, Shartzer Law Firm boasts lawyers with AV Martindale-Hubbell ratings and Top 40 Under 40 honors, indicating their peers recognize their skill in achieving justice best car accident attorney

Key Qualities of Top-Rated Car Accident Lawyers

Not all attorneys are equal. When searching for the best car accident attorney, look for these qualities:

• Experience in Car/Personal Injury Cases: Check how long the attorney has been practicing and focusing on accident claims. For example, Keller & Keller (founded 1936) has attorneys with decades of experience. Similarly, Jason Shartzer has 20+ years representing Indiana injury victims.
• Track Record of Success: Top lawyers often highlight past results. Keller & Keller advertises record settlements (e.g., over $20M in a tractor-trailer accident). While past results don’t guarantee future outcomes, a history of large verdicts or settlements suggests skill and tenacity.
• Peer Recognition and Awards: Look for “Super Lawyers,” “AV Preeminent” (Martindale-Hubbell), Million Dollar Advocates Forum, etc. For instance, Keller & Keller’s lawyers have earned AV Preeminent ratings and Team Green Law is part of top injury lawyer forums. Recognitions like these and client reviews indicate a lawyer respected by peers best car accident attorney
• Client Focus and Communication: The best lawyers provide clear, honest communication. Team Green Law emphasizes client support and a “Fair Fee Guarantee” – they promise never to take more in fees than the client recovers. Choose a firm or lawyer that listens to you and outlines every step.
• Free Consultation: Most reputable Indiana car accident attorneys offer a free initial consult. This lets you judge their professionalism without cost. During this meeting, they should discuss how they can help (evidence needs, deadlines, insurance). Avoid lawyers who rush you or pressure you to hire immediately best car accident attorney
• Local Presence: An Indiana-based attorney will have local court knowledge and can meet easily. For example, many clients prefer Indianapolis lawyers if the crash is in Marion County, or Fort Wayne lawyers for Allen County incidents.
• Specialized Skills: If your case involves specific issues, find a lawyer who handles those. For truck crashes, find an attorney experienced with FMCSA regulations. For motorcycles or DUI accidents, ensure the lawyer knows how to handle those liability scenarios.
• Ethics and Professionalism: Ensure the attorney is licensed and in good standing. (You can verify Indiana lawyers via IN Bar Association.) Look for honest reviews – reliable attorneys don’t make unrealistic promises like “100% guaranteed win.” best car accident attorney

By evaluating these factors, you’ll find a top rated car accident lawyer. In fact, directory sites like Super Lawyers list top Indiana attorneys (e.g., Jim Keller, Betsy Greene, Jason Shartzer) as “Top Rated” in motor vehicle accident cases best car accident attorney

What to Do Immediately After a Car Accident (Quick Checklist)

Acting promptly after a crash protects your health and your claim:

1. Seek Medical Attention: Call 911 or get evaluated even for minor pain. Some injuries (e.g., whiplash, concussions) aren’t obvious immediately. Documenting injuries early (with ER or doctor visits) creates critical medical records for your case.
2. Call the Police: A police report provides an official account of the accident, including preliminary fault assessment. Obtain a copy (or incident number) for your records.
3. Gather Information: Exchange names, contacts, insurance, and license info with all drivers involved. Also collect contact info for any witnesses. Take photos of vehicles, injuries, skid marks, and traffic signs at the scene.
4. Notify Your Insurance: Promptly inform your insurer about the accident (honestly). Let your lawyer communicate with them moving forward.
5. Avoid Hasty Statements: When speaking to other parties or insurance adjusters, stick to the facts and be cautious with statements. Don’t admit fault or exaggerate injuries on camera or to opposing insurers.
6. Contact a Car Accident Attorney: Ideally within days of the crash. Early engagement lets your lawyer gather police reports, talk to witnesses, and begin preserving evidence (like surveillance video) best car accident attorney

By following these steps, you strengthen your legal position. A car accident law office will help guide you through this process, ensuring nothing is overlooked.

15 Best Car Accident Attorneys in Indiana

Below are 15 highly regarded Indiana attorneys and law firms known for car accident cases. They are not ranked in any official order, but each has demonstrated expertise in personal injury:

1. Keller & Keller (Indianapolis) – A renowned personal injury firm (est. 1936) with $750M recovered. Lead attorney Jim Keller has decades of experience, and the firm offers a “Zero Fee Guarantee” (no fee unless you win). The team handles auto, truck, and wrongful death cases.
2. Shartzer Law Firm (Indianapolis) – Led by Jason Shartzer (20+ years of practice), this boutique firm is known for personalized service. They handle all types of vehicle accidents and offer multilingual support (27 languages). Shartzer Law is AV-rated and has received Super Lawyers selections best car accident attorney
3. Team Green Law (Indianapolis) – Founded by Collin Green (and others), Team Green is an award-winning injury firm. Their “Fair Fee Guarantee” ensures they never take more in fees than the client’s recovery. They emphasize a team approach and client care. Collin Green is a Top 100 trial lawyer nationally best car accident attorney
4. Yosha Law (Indianapolis) – A growing personal injury firm founded by Bryan Yosha. Brandon A. Yosha (partner) handles injury cases throughout Indiana. They emphasize client communication and have secured multi-million-dollar settlements for crash victims. (No-fee consultation.)
5. Hornak, Yoder & Associates (Indianapolis) – A large Indy-based firm. They have decades of experience in car and truck accident cases, often trying cases to verdict. Michael Hornak (partner) is known for aggressive representation and trial skill best car accident attorney
6. Ward & Ward (Indianapolis) – Donald Ward (founding partner) is a highly respected attorney with 40+ years’ experience. The firm is top-rated (often listed among “Best Car Accident Lawyers” in Indiana) and handles serious injury and wrongful death claims. Their lawyers hold numerous board certifications and awards (see their website) best car accident attorney
7. Keller & Keller (Franklin/Michigan) – The same Keller & Keller firm also serves Indiana clients through its Indiana branch. Randall L. Juergensen and others extend its coverage beyond Indy. They handle catastrophic collisions and catastrophic injury claims.
8. Bauer & Lato (Carmel) – With origins in Northwest Indiana, they have a Carmel office. This firm (former Keller & Keller attorneys) has over $1 billion in settlements. They focus exclusively on personal injury. In 2019, Bauer & Lato received a $5M+ verdict for a car crash.
9. Robertson Law (Fort Wayne) – Michael Robertson and Josh Cieslewicz handle Northern Indiana accident cases. They are AV-rated with 30+ years combined experience and have secured multi-million dollar settlements for car accident victims.
10. Hornak, Yoder & Associates (Kokomo) – Hornak has offices statewide, including Kokomo and Elkhart. R. Thomas Hornak is a Fellow of the American Board of Trial Advocates. The firm emphasizes trial experience and resources for serious accidents.
11. Thomas Law (Evansville) – Based in Southern Indiana, they handle car, truck, and motorcycle accidents. Attorney James Thomas has 30+ years of experience and is known regionally for personal injury litigation best car accident attorney
12. Green & Schultz (Evansville) – This Evansville firm (Betsy Greene) is actually the same Betsy from Super Lawyers in Indianapolis. They serve Southwestern Indiana and have a strong reputation in serious injury cases best car accident attorney
13. Craig, Kelley & Faultless (Fort Wayne) – Attorneys like William Hurst and Dave Craig are well-known in Northeast Indiana. They handle car, commercial truck, and injury cases, and the firm advertises recoveries of tens of millions for crash victims.
14. Keller & Keller (Terre Haute) – Keller & Keller also covers W. Indiana through their Terre Haute office. The local attorneys (like Brent Hurst) collaborate with the main team. They handle local car accident claims and coordinate with their larger Indiana network.
15. Team Green Law (Terre Haute) – Collin Green’s Team Green also has an office in Terre Haute, offering Indiana-wide service. They bring the same client-focused approach to west-central Indiana collisions.

Each of these firms/offices offers a free consultation and handles cases on contingency. They are listed as top attorneys in their regions either by peer reviews (Super Lawyers, Best Lawyers) or client ratings. If you need a car accident attorney, consider contacting one of these names to discuss your case. (Citations: many of the above attorneys are recognized by Super Lawyers and other industry rankings.) best car accident attorney

How to Choose the Right Attorney

Choosing the best lawyer is a personal decision. Here are steps to ensure a good match:

• Research Credentials: Check the lawyer’s credentials (bar status, special certifications, awards). Use state bar sites or independent directories.
• Read Client Reviews: Look for testimonials on Google, Avvo, or their website. Reviews may mention communication style, compassion, and results.
• Ask About Experience with Similar Cases: During consultation, ask if they’ve handled accidents like yours (e.g., Uber crashes, head-on collisions, rear-end, high-speed impact). A lawyer who has litigated similar cases will know what’s needed.
• Clarify Fees: Confirm the fee arrangement. Most firms do contingency, but ask for specifics (percentage, costs to advance). Attorneys must provide a written fee agreement. Make sure it’s understandable best car accident attorney
• Meet the Team: Some firms involve paralegals and investigators. Make sure you feel comfortable with the whole team, since you’ll likely interact with them best car accident attorney
• Discuss Communication: How will you receive updates? Will you have direct contact with the attorney? Clear communication is key during the long legal process best car accident attorney

Internal/External Links: Many of the lawyers above have detailed profiles and articles on their websites (e.g., Keller & Keller’s results page). You can read about their specific case results and approaches. Also, external resources like the Indiana Criminal Justice Institute (ICJI) provide crash data and insights on road safety best car accident attorney

FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

Q: When should I hire a car accident attorney?
A: You should contact an attorney as soon as possible after your crash, ideally within days. Early involvement allows the lawyer to quickly obtain the police report, identify witnesses, and preserve evidence (like traffic camera footage). Even if you’re unsure of injury severity, a lawyer can advise you whether your case warrants representation. Remember, Indiana’s statute of limitations for personal injury is 2 years from the accident date, so don’t delay best car accident attorney

Q: How do I know if I have a strong car accident case?
A: A good case typically involves clear liability (the other driver was clearly at fault, e.g., red light violation) and significant damages (medical treatment, lost wages). However, even if fault is partly yours or injuries seem minor at first, you should consult a lawyer. They will evaluate all factors, including evidence and medical opinions. Attorneys often handle cases others might overlook best car accident attorney

Q: Can I still recover if I was partly at fault?
A: Yes. Indiana follows modified comparative fault: you can recover even if you are partly to blame, as long as your fault is 50% or less. For example, if you are 40% at fault, you can recover 60% of the total damages. If you are more than 50% at fault, you cannot recover anything. Proving the other driver’s majority fault (over 50%) is often key, which is why having an attorney gather evidence (photos, witness testimony) is so important.

Q: What is an Uber accident lawyer and do I need one?
A: An Uber accident lawyer specializes in rideshare collisions. These cases involve special insurance rules: if the Uber driver had a passenger or was en route to pick one, Uber provides liability coverage; if the driver was logged out, their personal insurance applies. The liability can be complex, involving Uber’s policy, the driver’s policy, and other drivers. A rideshare attorney understands these rules and knows how to make claims under each applicable policy. If your crash involved an Uber or Lyft, choosing a lawyer familiar with rideshare law is crucial.

Q: What should I avoid doing after a crash to protect my case?
A: Right after the accident: don’t admit fault or minimize your injuries on camera or to the other party. Insurance adjusters sometimes record statements; be honest but brief. Also avoid posting details or photos of the crash on social media; adjusters may use that against you. Afterward, follow medical advice carefully. Failing to treat could be used to argue your injuries aren’t serious. Instead, document all your medical visits and gather bills/receipts; your lawyer will use these to show damages.

Q: How can I be sure this article is credible?
A: We have cited reputable sources throughout. Crash statistics are from the Indiana Criminal Justice Institute and official fact books. Attorney information comes from law firm websites and recognized rankings. Always cross-check info with official legal sources or by consulting a qualified attorney for personalized advice.

Q: I live outside Indiana. Can I still use an Indiana attorney?
A: Only if the accident happened in Indiana or involves Indiana law. Attorneys are licensed by state. If you live elsewhere, you’d generally hire a lawyer licensed in the state where the crash occurred. For example, if you were in a car accident in Atlanta, an Atlanta car accident attorney would be appropriate. Our mention of Charlotte, Houston, and Atlanta attorneys is for context: legal processes are similar, but you need a lawyer admitted in the accident’s state.

Conclusion and Call to Action

Finding the best car accident attorney in Indiana means considering experience, track record, and client fit. This guide covered important factors – Indiana’s crash statistics and fault laws, how attorneys help, and a list of reputable lawyers (including Keller & Keller and Shartzer Law). Whether you were hit by an impaired driver, collided with an Uber, or had a freeway pile-up, a dedicated lawyer can handle the legal burden while you recover.

If you’ve been injured in an Indiana car crash, don’t wait. Reach out to one of the top attorneys listed above or visit their websites for a free consultation. They can explain your rights and the next steps. We encourage you to share this guide on social media to help others who need legal help, and leave a comment below if you have questions or want to share your experience. Your feedback helps build a community of informed readers and supports better recovery for crash victims.

Sources: Indiana traffic and crash data are from the Indiana Criminal Justice Institute and legal analytics. Attorney credentials and firm accomplishments are cited from law firm profiles and reviews. Secondary city stats (Charlotte, Houston, Atlanta) are included to illustrate context. These sources provide factual backing for the information above.